Skip to Main content
HAVE YOUR CHECK NUMBER READY UPON ARRIVAL

  • Bagelmasters

Currently not accepting online orders

Bagelmasters Shrewsbury, NJ

661 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ
BAGELS
MINI BAGELS
BREAKFAST
DRINKS
SANDWICHES & WRAPS
SPREADS
BOARS HEAD BY THE 1/4 POUND
RETAIL
SNACKS
SALADS
GIFT CARDS
BY THE POUND

Featured Items

  • Bacon Egg & Cheese

    Bacon, egg and cheese on your choice of bread or bagel
    $6.95

  • Pork Roll Egg & Cheese

    Pork roll, egg and cheese on your choice of bread or bagel
    $6.95

  • Bagel w/ Cream Cheese

    Choice of fresh baked bagel with cream cheese
    $3.95

BAGELS

LIMIT 2 DOZEN PER ORDER(45 MINUTE LEAD TIME

  • One Bagel

    Single bagel, baked fresh daily!
    $1.50

  • 6 Bagels

    $9.00

  • Dozen Bagels

    Bakers dozen of freshly baked bagels!
    $18.00

  • Bagel w/ Cream Cheese

    Choice of fresh baked bagel with cream cheese
    $3.95

  • Bagel w/ Butter

    Choice of fresh baked bagel with butter
    $3.25

  • Bagel w/ Specialty Spread

    Choose from a variety of our homemade spreads on one of our fresh baked bagel
    $4.50

  • Bagel w/ Lox Spread

    Choice of fresh baked bagel with our home made lox spread
    $4.75

  • Bagel with Cream Cheese and Butter

    Choice of fresh baked bagel with both cream cheese and butter
    $3.75

  • Bagel w/ Vegan Plain Cream Cheese

    Try our new coconut based vegan spread! Thick and creamy like the real thing and the best tasting vegan spread we've tried so far!
    $5.60

  • Bagel w/ Vegan Vegetable Cream Cheese

    $7.30

  • Bagel w/ Peanut Butter

    $3.25

  • Bagel w/ Peanut Butter & Jelly

    $3.50

  • Bagel w/ Cream Cheese & Jelly

    $3.75

  • Bagel w/ Peanut Butter & Butter

    $3.25

  • Bagel w/Butter & Jelly

    $3.00

  • Bagel w/Jelly

    $2.25

  • Bagel w/ Cheese

    $2.70

MINI BAGELS

Mini Bagel

LIMIT 2 DOZEN PER ORDER(45 MINUTE LEAD TIME)

  • One Mini Bagel

    $0.90

  • 6 Mini Bagels

    6 fresh baked mini bagels
    $5.40

  • Dozen Mini Bagels

    Dozen fresh baked mini bagels
    $10.80

  • 6 Mini Rainbow

    $9.00

  • Dozen Mini Rainbow

    $18.00

  • Mini Bagel With Cream Cheese

    $2.85

  • Mini Bagel w/ Butter

    $2.05

  • Mini Bagel w/ Specialty Spread

    $3.25

  • Mini Bagel w/ Cream Cheese & Jelly

    $2.60

  • Mini Bagel w/ Peanut Butter

    $2.05

  • Mini Bagel w/ Lox Spread

    $3.50

  • Mini Bagel w/ Peanut Butter & Jelly

    $2.00

  • Mini Bagel w/ Vegan Plain Cream Cheese

    $4.25

  • Mini Bagel w/ Vegan Vegetable Cream Cheese

    $4.60

  • Mini Bagel w/ Butter & Jelly

    $2.00

  • Mini Bagel w/ Cheese

    $2.20

  • Mini Bagel w/ Cream Cheese and Butter

    $1.25

  • Mini W/PB & But

    $2.00

  • Mini Bagel w/ Jelly

    $1.80

BREAKFAST

Breakfast

  • Nova Lox & Cream Cheese Sandwich

    $10.25

  • Avocado Toast

    $4.75

  • Bacon Egg & Cheese

    Bacon, egg and cheese on your choice of bread or bagel
    $6.95

  • Bacon & Egg Sandwich

    Bacon and egg (NO CHEESE) on your choice of bread or bagel
    $6.00

  • Bacon & Cheese Sandwich

    Bacon and Cheese (NO EGG) on your choice of bread or bagel
    $5.00

  • Bacon Sandwich

    Bacon only on your choice of bread or bagel
    $4.35

  • Pork Roll Egg & Cheese

    Pork roll, egg and cheese on your choice of bread or bagel
    $6.95

  • Pork Roll & Egg Sandwich

    Pork roll and egg (NO CHEESE) on your choice of bread or bagel
    $6.00

  • Pork Roll & Cheese Sandwich

    Pork roll and Cheese (NO EGG) on your choice of bread or bagel
    $5.00

  • Pork Roll Sandwich

    $4.35

  • Sausage Egg & Cheese

    Sausage, egg and cheese on your choice of bread or bagel
    $6.95

  • Sausage & Egg Sandwich

    Sausage & egg on your choice of bread or bagel
    $6.00

  • Sausage & Cheese Sandwich

    Sausage and cheese (NO EGG) on your choice of bread or bagel
    $5.00

  • Sausage Sandwich

    $4.35

  • Egg Sandwich

    $3.95

  • Egg & Cheese Sandwich

    $4.90

  • Belly Buster

    2 Eggs, Pork Roll, Sausage, Bacon & a Hash Brown on your choice of bread or bagel
    $11.99

  • Turkey Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich

    $7.70

  • Turkey Bacon & Egg Sandwich

    $6.75

  • Turkey Bacon & Cheese Sandwich

    $5.75

  • Turkey Bacon Sandwich

    $5.10

  • Ham Egg & Cheese

    $9.30

  • Ham & Egg Sandwich

    $7.35

  • Hot Deli Ham/Cheese

    $6.75

  • Steak Egg & Cheese

    $9.85

  • BLT Sandwich

    $6.05

  • Turkey Egg & Cheese

    $9.80

  • Grilled Cheese Sandwich

    $5.20

  • Single Egg on a Plate

    $2.45

  • Avocado Sandwich

    $5.00

  • Turkey & Egg Sandwich

    $8.00

  • Hot Turkey/Cheese

    OUT OF STOCK
    $7.40

Breakfast Wraps

  • Power Wrap

    Turkey, Three Egg Whites and American Cheese
    $10.50

  • Featherweight Wrap

    Three Egg Whites, with Red & Green Peppers, Tomatoes, Onions and American Cheese
    $8.25

  • Western Wrap

    Ham, Three Eggs Scrambled, Red & Green Peppers and Onions
    $11.25

  • Patron Wrap

    Three Egg Whites, Fresh Spinach and Vermont Cheddar Cheese
    $8.50

  • RPM Wrap

    Three Eggs, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Spinach and Mozzarella
    $9.75

Mini Bagel Breakfast

  • Mini Bagel Turkey & Egg

    OUT OF STOCK
    $7.40

  • Mini Bagel Hot Turkey & Cheese

    OUT OF STOCK
    $6.70

  • Mini Bagel Turkey, Egg & Cheese

    OUT OF STOCK
    $9.35

  • Mini Bagel w/ Nova Lox

    $5.25

  • Mini Bagel Turkey Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich

    OUT OF STOCK
    $7.15

  • Mini Bagel Turkey Bacon & Egg Sandwich

    $6.15

  • Mini Bagel Pork Roll Egg & Cheese

    $6.35

  • Mini Bagel Sausage Egg & Cheese Sandwich

    $6.35

  • Mini Bagel Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich

    $6.35

  • Mini Bagel Egg & Cheese

    $3.80

  • Mini BLT

    $3.65

  • Mini Bagel Pork Roll & Egg Sandwich

    $5.25

  • Mini Bagel Egg Sandwich

    $3.05

  • Mini Bagel Sausage & Egg Sandwich

    $5.60

  • Mini Bagel Sausage Sandwich

    $3.25

  • Mini Bagel Nova Lox & Cream Cheese Sandwich

    $6.25

  • Mini Bagel Bacon & Egg Sandwich

    $5.40

  • Mini Bagel Pork Roll & Cheese Sandwich

    $3.35

SIDES

  • Side Hashbrowns

    Comes with 2 hashbrowns
    $3.10

  • Side of Homefries

    $2.15

  • Side of Bacon

    $2.75

  • Side of Turkey Bacon

    $3.50

  • Side of Pork Roll

    $3.00

  • Side of Sausage

    $2.75

  • Side of Avocado

    $2.75

  • Side of Tomatoes

    $1.95

  • Side of Onions

    $1.95

  • Side of Capers

    $1.55

  • Side of Pickles(5)

    $1.25

  • Side of Jalapenos

    $1.25

DRINKS

Cold Beverages

  • Battenkill Chocolate Milk

    $5.00

  • Tropicana Orange (Pt)

    $3.95

  • Poland Spring Water

    $1.75

  • Yoohoo

    $2.75

  • Tropicana Apple

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.95

  • Tropicana Orange (46 oz.)

    $7.50

  • 12oz Iced Coffee

    $3.75

  • 16oz Iced Coffee

    $4.50

  • Small Fountain Drink

    $3.25

  • Large Fountain Drink

    $4.00

  • Prime Cherry Freeze

    $4.50

Joe's Iced Tea

  • Joe's Half & Half

    $3.75

  • Joe's Strawberry Lemonade

    $3.75

  • Joe's Raspberry

    $3.75

  • Joe's Peach

    $3.75

  • Joe's Lemon

    $3.75

  • Joe's Black Tea

    $3.75

Sodas

  • Pepsi

    $3.75

  • Diet Pepsi

    $3.75

  • Ginger Ale

    $3.75

  • Orange Crush

    $3.75

  • Seltzer Can

    $2.00

Jarritos Soda

  • Jarritos Fruit Punch

    $3.00

Snapple

  • Snapple Lemon Tea

    $3.00

  • Snapple Diet Lemon Tea

    $3.00

  • Snapple Raspberry

    $3.00

  • Snapple Peach

    $3.00

  • Snapple Diet Peach

    $3.00

  • Snapple Orangeade

    $3.00

  • Snapple Apple

    $3.00

  • Snapple Kiwi Strawberry

    $3.00

Naked Drinks

  • Naked Strawberry Banana

    $5.50

  • Naked Green Machine

    $5.50

  • Naked Blue Machine

    $5.50

Gatorade & Energy Drinks

  • Red Gatorade

    $3.25

  • Blue Gatorade

    $3.25

  • Yellow Gatorade

    $3.25

  • Red Bull

    $4.25

  • Red Bull Sugar-Free

    $4.25

Hot Beverages

  • Small Regular Coffee

    $2.50

  • Large Regular Coffee

    $2.75

  • Small Tea

    $1.80

  • Large Tea

    $2.00

  • Small Hot Chocolate

    $2.00

Box of Joe

  • Box of Joe - Regular

    $25.00

  • Box of Joe - Decaf

    $25.00

  • Box of Joe - Hazelnut

    OUT OF STOCK
    $21.50

SANDWICHES & WRAPS

Sandwiches

  • The #3

    Ham, Turkey, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Oil & Vinegar on your choice of bread or bagel
    $10.75

  • Farmhouse Club

    Chicken Salad, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Cranberry Sauce on your choice of bread or bagel
    $10.50

  • Roast Beef Club

    Deluxe Roast Beef, Lettuce, Tomato and Bacon on your choice of bread or bagel
    $10.90

  • Ham Club

    Boiled Ham, Lettuce, Tomato and Bacon on your choice of bread or bagel
    $9.90

  • Corned Beef Reuben

    Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut
    $11.70

  • Triple Decker

    Turkey, Corned Beef and Pastrami, with Cole Slaw and Russian on your choice of bread
    $10.35

  • Masters Melt

    Solid White Tuna, Muenster Cheese and Tomato on your choice of bread or bagel
    $8.65

  • Pastrami Reuben

    Pastrami, Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut
    $11.70

  • Pizza Bagel w/ Mozzarella

    $5.55

  • Pizza Bagel w/ Mozzarella & Pepperoni

    $6.85

  • Turkey Club

    Oven Gold Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato and Bacon on your choice of bread or bagel
    $9.90

  • Turkey Melt

    Oven Gold Turkey, Roasted Red Peppers and Swiss Cheese on your choice of bread or bagel
    $9.10

  • Masters Grill

    Smoked Turkey, Muenster Cheese, Bacon and Russian Dressing on your choice of bread or bagel
    $10.00

  • Honey Combo

    Honey Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Honey Mustard Dressing on your choice of bread or bagel
    $9.90

  • Cheesesteak

    Deluxe Roast Beef, American Cheese, Red & Green Peppers
    $11.50

  • Sloppy Joe

    $10.25

  • Masters Choice

    Cracked Peppermill Turkey, Havarti with Jalapeno Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Russian Dressing on your choice of bread or bagel
    $10.00

Wraps

  • The Brooklyn Wrap

    Mozzarella, Tomato, Spinach, Olive Oil & Pesto
    $9.00

  • Pollo Loco Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, Onions, Peppers, Jalapenos, Avocado, Havarti, Chipotle Sauce
    $11.30

  • All-American Wrap

    Grilled Chicken Breast with Lettuce, Tomato and Crispy Bacon
    $9.55

  • Chicken Caesar Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Grated Parmesan Cheese and Caesar Dressing
    $9.55

  • Veggie Wrap

    Shredded Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Red Peppers, Green Peppers, Cucmbers & Jalapenos with Ranch Dressing
    $6.25

  • Ultimate Wrap

    Grilled Chicken Topped with Tomato, Melted Mozzarella and Balsamic Vinegar
    $9.75

  • Delight Wrap

    Roast Beef, Lettuce, Tomato and Vermont Cheddar Cheese covered with Russian Dressing
    $10.25

  • Pollo Chipotle Wrap

    Grilled Chicken with Avocado Topped with Homemade Chipotle cream and Melted Mozzarella
    $9.95

  • Yankee Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers, Sundried Tomatoes, Melted Mozzarella and Balsamic Vinegar
    $10.15

BUILD IT

  • Roasted Turkey Sandwich

    $8.90

  • Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich

    $8.90

  • Peppermill Turkey Sandwich

    $8.90

  • Smoked Turkey Sandwich

    $8.90

  • Roast Beef Sandwich

    $9.95

  • Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich

    $8.75

  • Boiled Ham Sandwich

    $8.25

  • Genoa Salami Sandwich

    $7.75

  • Corned Beef Sandwich

    $11.00

  • Pastrami Sandwich

    $11.00

  • Egg Salad Sandwich

    $6.45

  • Tuna Salad Sandwich

    $6.75

  • Chicken Salad Sandwich

    $7.95

  • Whitefish Salad Sandwich

    $8.75

Mini Bagel BYO Sandwich

  • Mini Bagel Roasted Turkey Sandwich

    $4.85

  • Mini Bagel Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich

    $4.85

  • Mini Bagel Peppermill Turkey Sandwich

    $4.85

  • Mini Bagel Smoked Turkey Sandwich

    $4.85

  • Mini Bagel Roast Beef Sandwich

    $5.50

  • Mini Bagel Boiled Ham Sandwich

    $4.45

  • Mini Bagel Egg Salad Sandwich

    $4.10

  • Mini Bagel Tuna Salad Sandwich

    $4.35

  • Mini Bagel Chicken Salad Sandwich

    $4.55

  • Mini Bagel Whitefish Salad Sandwich

    $4.60

SPREADS

  • 1/2 lb. Plain Cream Cheese

    $4.05

  • 1/2 lb Salted Whipped Butter

    $5.05

  • 1/2 lb. Scallion Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Vegetable Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Strawberry Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Blueberry Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Lox Spread Cream Cheese

    $6.10

  • 1/2 lb. Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Olive & Pimento Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Apple Cinnamon Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Jalapeno Cheddar Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Bacon Cheddar Cream Cheese

    $5.95

  • 1/2 lb. Vegan Plain Cream Cheese

    $9.75

  • 1/2 lb. Vegan Vegetable Cream Cheese

    $11.50

  • 1\2 LB Strawberry Jelly

    $3.90

BOARS HEAD BY THE 1/4 POUND

Meats

  • Nova Lox (1/4 lb)

    $8.38

  • Boiled Ham (1/4 lb)

    $2.49

  • Roast Beef (1/4 lb)

    $3.98

  • Corned Beef (1/4 lb)

    $5.00

  • Roasted Turkey (1/4 lb)

    $3.05

  • Cracked Peppermill Turkey (1/4 lb)

    $3.05

  • Smoked Turkey (1/4 lb)

    $3.05

  • Honey Maple Turkey (1/4 lb)

    $3.05

  • Pastrami (1/4 lb)

    $5.00

  • Trenton Pork Roll (1/4 lb)

    $2.15

  • Genoa Salami (1/4 lb)

    $2.64

Salads

  • Chicken Salad (1/4 lb)

    $2.49

  • Tuna Salad (1/4 lb)

    $2.46

  • White Fish Salad (1/4 lb)

    $3.75

  • Egg Salad (1/4 lb)

    $2.40

  • Cole Slaw (1/4 lb)

    $1.04

  • Macaroni Salad (1/4 lb)

    $1.04

  • Potato Salad (1/4 lb)

    $1.04

Cheese

SOLD IN 1/4 lb INCREMENTS

  • Boars Head American (1/4 lb)

    $1.94

  • Swiss (1/4 lb)

    $2.16

  • Provolone (1/4 lb)

    $2.29

  • Havarti w/ Jalapeno (1/4 lb)

    $2.24

  • Muenster (1/4 lb)

    $1.99

  • Vermont Cheddar (1/4 lb)

    OUT OF STOCK
    $2.29

  • Land O Lakes White (1/4 lb)

    $2.24

  • Mozzarella (1/4 lb)

    $2.24

RETAIL

Merchandise

  • Black Heavyweight Hoodie

    13.5 oz 100% ring-spun cotton, double ribbing side panels for stretch, cross grain to limit shrinkage
    $70.00

  • Unisex Black "Swirl" Tee

    $27.00

  • Unisex Vintage Grey Tee

    $25.00

  • Unisex Vintage Navy Tee

    $25.00

  • Unisex Vintage Yellow Tee

    $25.00

  • Unisex Vintage Green Tee

    $25.00

  • "My Everything" Adult Vintage White

    $25.00

  • Women's Slouchy Tank

    $26.00

  • Women's Flowy Crew

    $25.00

  • Long Sleeve Crew Tie-Dye Tee 10% OFF!

    $28.80

  • North Face Lightweight Fleece Black 50% OFF!

    Bagelmasters Branded 3/4 Zip Lightweight North Face Fleece
    $40.00

  • North Face Lightweight Fleece Grey 50% OFF!

    Bagelmasters Branded 3/4 Zip Lightweight North Face Fleece
    $40.00

  • Kid's Vintage Grey

    $18.00

  • "My Everything" Toddler White

    $20.00

  • Black "Dad Hat" w/ Bagel Master Logo

    $30.00

  • Pink Baseball Cap

    $27.00

  • Navy Canvas Snapback Hat

    OUT OF STOCK
    $23.50

  • Black Canvas Tote

    $10.00

  • Natural Canvas Tote

    $10.00

  • Unlimited Coffee Mug

    Purchase our Bagelmasters tumbler and receive free coffee for one year from date of purchase
    $150.00

  • Koozie

    $2.00

SNACKS

Chips

  • Deep River

    $2.00

  • Lg Wise Bags

    $2.50

Cookies

  • Chocolate Chip Cookie

    $2.50

Muffins

  • Corn Muffin

    Fresh baked in store daily!
    $2.50

  • Cinnamon Coffee Muffin

    Fresh baked in store daily!
    $2.50

  • Chocolate Chocolate Chip Muffin

    Fresh baked in store daily!
    $2.50

  • Blueberry Muffin

    Fresh baked in store daily!
    $2.50

Crumb Cakes

  • Plain Crumb Cake

    $2.50

Bagel Chips

  • Bagel Chips

    $5.00

SALADS

  • Honey Mustard Chicken Salad

    $9.15

  • Chef Salad

    $9.15

  • Garden Salad

    $7.25

  • Chicken Salad Platter

    $7.55

  • Tuna Salad Platter

    $7.55

GIFT CARDS

  • $5 GIFT CARD

    $5.00

  • $10 GIFT CARD

    $10.00

  • $15 GIFT CARD

    $15.00

  • $20 GIFT CARD

    $20.00

  • $25 GIFT CARD

    $25.00

  • $30 GIFT CARD

    $30.00

  • $35 GIFT CARD

    $35.00

  • $40 GIFT CARD

    $40.00

  • $45 GIFT CARD

    $45.00

  • $50 GIFT CARD

    $50.00

BY THE POUND

Meats

SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE

  • Oven Roasted Turkey (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $12.45

  • Cracked Peppermill Turkey (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $12.45

  • Smoked Turkey (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $12.45

  • Honey Maple Turkey (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $12.45

  • Boiled Ham (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $9.95

  • Roast Beef (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $15.95

  • Corned Beef (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $19.95

  • Pastrami (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $19.95

  • Trenton Pork Roll (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $8.45

  • Genoa Salami (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $10.55

Salads

SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE

  • Chicken Salad (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $9.95

  • Tuna Salad (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $9.85

  • White Fish Salad (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $14.99

  • Egg Salad (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $9.65

  • Cole Slaw (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $4.15

  • Macaroni Salad (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $4.15

  • Potato Salad (lb)

    SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
    $4.15
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

16oz Iced Coffee

$4.50
Request advisory
No substitutes. Additions may be charged extra.
1

Bagelmasters Location and Hours

(732) 607-5797
661 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
Closed • Opens Friday at 6AM
Facebook logoInstagram logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement